Monday, April 17, 2017

Trusting Others

From an early age, we've been told to not talk to strangers. However, society has begun to shift its stance on that classic piece of advice. Trusting others has become the norm with the expansion of mobile applications, especially with organizations and apps like Yelp, Uber, Lyft, VRBO, and AirBnb (just to name a few). Last summer, for example, I needed to attend a tech conference in Texas, but all of the hotels in the area were booked, so I turned to Airbnb. Never having used it, I hesitantly booked a room in some guy’s 4-star rating townhouse in downtown Houston. I also moved around Houston via Uber to get from place to place (and never had a problem). This experience went really well and since then, I've been actively looking for other places to stay at and using ride-sharing apps more often. However, I realized that not everyone’s experience is like this. Which brings up many questions, but one of the most important ones being: Who can you trust, and should you?

Who Can You Trust?

The Forbes article "AirBnb and The Internet Trust Issue: Who Can You Trust Online?" asks this question and delves into how people have become so reliant on these online rating systems and applications without taking into considerations the possible outcomes, such as being scammed or putting ourselves in danger. Similarly, "How Airbnb and Lyft Finally Got Americans to Trust Each Other", also puts into perspective how we have become so reliant and trusting, and it shockingly puts into perspective that "We are entrusting complete strangers with our most valuable possessions, our personal experiences—and our very lives. In the process, we are entering a new era of Internet-enabled intimacy."

Along with this new era of trust and intimacy, a new study by Zendrive and Aite Group has found that "jumping in the car with an Uber/ Lyft driver is generally safer than getting behind the wheel yourself" (http://www.fareestimate.com/news/uber-lyft-safety/). If it seems that using these applications have become the norm (and some studies are proving that it is safe), do we have anything to worry about?

Trust and Safety On Both Ends

"Uber and Lyft Drivers Work Dangerous Jobs- but they're on their own" also brings to light something that I hadn't considered. Yes, we as consumers are risking our safety, but those who are providing the service are in just as exposed and vulnerable. The article (mentioned above) looks at some "Uber horror stories" and videos where some experiences are more terrifying than others, such as the Uber driver who was beaten by a drunken Taco Bell executive, or a doctor who tried kicking his driver in the face before trashing his car. These horror stories don't just stop at Uber or Lyft, they also extend to AirBnb and VRBO. The following is a video on an "AirBnb Home Rental Nightmare" on behalf of ABC News:




Why is this controversial? 

While the Internet is connecting us all, and providing ways for us all to move around- whether in others' cars or into others' homes, we need to ask ourselves if we should be as trusting. There are both pros and cons to using these services, and in exchanging information like this. In reality, we don't know whose 5-star rated car we are getting into when we need to go from point A to B. But at times, it doesn't matter, as long as we can get from point A to B. If you take away anything from this write-up, I'd suggest that you consider whose house you're staying at, or whose car you're jumping into, and try to stay safe so that your experience can be an enjoyable one versus a nightmare that puts you in harm's way.



6 comments:

  1. Hi Alexandra! I was just curious if AirBnb has set in place any type of processes for those that use their services to try and mitigate any risk involved in the use of the company (such as checking those that are looking to stay somewhere, such as background checks). I saw in the video how it said AirBnb will cover up to $1 million in damages to homeowners, but is there anything that AirBnb is doing currently in order to attempt to reduce the amount of damages or incidents that may cause them to payout this money to the homeowners. I know that they stated that these types of incidents are rare, but still cause the payout of damages to cover the homeowners loses. Or is the one renting completely liable for the damages done?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Matthew,

      So I just checked, and it seems that AirBnb has some rules and guarantees set in place for any damages that occur. The website states that: "We’re committed to creating a safe and trusted community around the world. Though property damage is rare, we understand you may need protection. The Host Guarantee will reimburse eligible hosts for damages up to $1,000,000."

      There's more information on that here: https://www.airbnb.com/guarantee.

      However, I couldn't really find anything else stating if there's a prevention for any of the damages or incidents, or any other details.

      Delete
  2. Hi Alexandra,

    I think your topic is interesting and this topic reminds an affair that occurred about Uber China: the "ghost driver". Many Chinese passengers were assigned drivers with the Uber app but the drivers will never arrive to pick up their customers or answer phones. However, the passengers will still be charged by about 10 Yuan and the trips are shown as finished. Moreover, these drivers’ photos are often shown as blurry, dark, and ghost-like pictures. Those are computer-generated fake photos.

    I believe that the ghost drivers hold some responsibility of this event but Uber China should be blames as well. From this affair, we can find that trust also based on the effective management. If Uber performed an effective checking process on the drivers’ license, ID, photo, and other information, the ghost driver can be prevented. And customers can trust Uber China better.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Xintong,

      Interesting point! I definitely agree with you that Uber needs to improve their management of their drivers and hold them more accountable so that the customer is not paying for their ghost drivers. By improving this aspect, I could see a stronger relationship and trust resulting from that with Uber China and its customers. There needs to be a defined list of requirements and documents, as you mentioned, for the drivers to provide and prove their legitimacy. However, I wonder how long this would take to implement and how quickly it would be adopted by the Uber drivers.

      Delete
  3. Interesting topic. We talked about Air B&B in Entr class and it kind of relates to what you said in class. You cant trust what you read, nor can you always trust anyone over the app. Uber works hard to keeps its clients safe and happy but you cant control everything that happens in every car ride.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Mozamil,

      I definitely agree that it's hard to know what and who you can/ should trust. I agree that Uber's focus is on keeping its clients happy, but then that also brings up the thought of- if they're focusing so heavily on their clients, where do their 'employees' stand?

      Delete